Judging Rulebook · commit.show

Judging RulebookEvery project on commit.show is scored on a transparent rubric. Total = 100 points:

Audit (50 pt) · automated rubric · production-readiness signals from your repo + live URL

Scout Forecast (30 pt) · tier-gated humans place predictions on which projects will graduate

Community Signal (20 pt) · views, comments, applauds, return visits

Audit pillar · 14 production-readiness framesThe engine scores 14 axes: Lighthouse (Perf · A11y · BP · SEO), Live URL health, completeness signals (og:image · favicon · meta · etc.), production maturity (tests · CI · observability · TS-strict · lockfile · LICENSE · responsive), source hygiene, tech-layer diversity, Build Brief integrity. Calibration baseline pinned to 5 reference OSS projects (supabase, shadcn-ui, cal.com, vercel/ai, vibe).Graduation tiers

Valedictorian · top 0.5% (1 per season)

Honors · top 5%

Graduate · top 14.5%

Rookie Circle · everyone else · next-audition cohort

Anti-gamingAudit-count tiebreaker · projects can't farm score from infinite re-audits. Self-vote blocked. Applauds carry zero leaderboard weight (only Community Signal proxy). Suspicious patterns silently muted, not publicly shamed.Run an audit yourselfnpx commitshow@latest audit github.com/owner/repoOr fetch from any agent runtime: GET https://api.commit.show/audit?repo=owner/repo&format=md · see /llms.txt for the full agent integration guide.Cross-links · Products · Scouts · Library · Rulebook · Audit method · CommunityPrivacy · Terms · operated by Madeflo Inc., a Delaware corporation.